Essential Leadership Skills: Employee Engagement ·
Do you know how engaged your employees are? These statistics tell that you probably don’t.
While doing some research on productivity and high performance in the workplaces, I came across some very interesting stats about employee engagement, and how massive impact it (or rather the lack of it) can have on the bottom line of the company.
When you talk with leaders of different companies and ask what is their company’s greatest asset, the answer, “employees”, “team” or “people” comes up almost without exception. The other top 2 asset most often seems to be “products” or “services”, which are off course built and delivered by the people of the company. This is especially true on modern high tech and high skill industries that don’t need to rely on massive manufacturing plants with highly optimised manufacturing processes.
Here are a few facts about the current employee engagement numbers to open the discussion. Numbers are collected from Gallup.com & HBR reports and are global averages, unless otherwise stated:
- 18% of employees are actively disengaged from their work.
- 67% of employees are somewhat disengaged from their work.
- 15% of employees are engaged in their work.
One finding that surprised me as a Western European was that the percentage of fully engaged people is actually much lower for our region than it is for the rest of the world: The number is dismally low 10%. For example, for the US & Canadian companies, the number is quite a bit better: 31%. Also, Latin America shows better numbers at 27%.
This means that only 1 in 10 people working here is really engaged in his work, and truly enjoys it, and pro-actively seeks to improve his own performance, and the performance of his team and the whole company. He has probably collected several additional responsibilities and tries to push everyone around him to perform better. He might be also quite frustrated with some of his colleagues for not showing the same level of interest in the work, and he probably wishes that the management above him would figure out ways to get others to join his enthusiasm.
The next 7 people are “satisfied” with their work, meaning they don’t mind it, as long as they get paid, and they don’t have to put too much effort in it. In other words, they are indifferent to their company and work. These people are not particularly interested in improving themselves regarding their work performance, and won’t be pro-actively thinking about ways to improve the results of their own work, their team’s work and much less of the whole company. There are off course varying levels of disengagement here, and other people are somewhat more engaged and active, but still they are not engaged enough to put in their best performance constantly.Then there are the 2 people in every 10 who pretty much hate their work, and would rather be anywhere else. Whenever they can, they avoid working and they avoid responsibility as much as possible. These people will constantly see unsolvable problems in their work, and give up easily if they face any challenges. They also expect that someone else will come to fix the problems and take the responsibility, if they wait long enough. As you realize, employees with this mindset can be very damaging to the whole culture and productivity of the company if they are left to act as they wish. On top of creating just the minimum expected value, they provide distractions to others, and test the limits of what their company and managers allow them to do (or not to do), and thus risk lowering the standard for the whole company, if their actions and results are silently approved.
What do these engagement numbers really mean for a company?To put this in correct perspective, it is estimated that the disengagement costs an unbelievable $550 billion in a year for American companies in lost productivity, and that is the cost for a country, that is not even close to the lowest engagement numbers. There are several measurable factors from customer satisfaction to employee retention and revenue growth that seem to be affected by engagement numbers and resulting productivity variances, but for me, the simplest one is profit: The top quartile of the companies on engagement scale turn 21% more profit, than those on the lowest quartile. 21% more profit is quite a significant indication that the engagement truly matters, and that there is a clear relation between engagement level and company success.
To make these numbers a bit more concrete, you could also make a simple calculation for your own team or company of 10 employees:
If each of your employees’ maximum theoretical output would be worth 15.000€ for your company, and you would be somewhere in Western Europe, with average engagement rates, your calculation could look something like this:
- My (highly) engaged employee 15. 000€/month x 1 = 15.000€
- My somewhat disengaged employees 11.000€/month x 7 = 77.000€
- My actively disengaged employees 6.000€/month x 2 = 12.000€
- Total 104.000€/month out of 150.000€ (max potential)
- Loss of value 54.000€/month and 552.000€ /pa
Food for thought for any company owner or a leaderSo, as a leader or a company owner, do you know how engaged your people are, and are you actively leading in ways that promote the employee engagement (or at least know to avoid things that increase the disengagement)? The research data reveals that management’s performance accounts for 70% of the variance of the employee engagement (Gallup.com). And yet further, another research report tells us that engagement flows from the top of the company downwards: First from the executives to the middle-management, and then through middle-management the employees. And the chain must be complete, it can’t be patched up anyone else in the company, if the top executives do not take care of their extremely important part. What does it tell about you as a leader, if your most valuable asset is constantly working far from its optimal performance and is not fully engaged in the work? If we would be talking about your manufacturing line, I bet it would be your top priority to get it working on full capacity as soon as possible, as you can easily calculate the loss of money for every minute that the machinery is not running as it is supposed to. When talking about people, and especially those doing knowledge work including creativity and problem solving, the engagement level, and resulting productivity, is however, not so easily measured. It is very hard to define what is an optimal performance level for a knowledge worker, and thus the expectations are very fuzzy, and so is too often the engagement level of the employees and the resulting productivity.
What about the employees, aren’t they responsible at all?While the engagement “energy” flows from the top, there is still a fair share of responsibility on the employees side, and the attitude and mindset of an employee can greatly impact how he experiences his work and the working environment. However, if there are significant factors missing on the management side (such as company vision, mission and targets on company or personal levels, or the worst of all, visible engagement of the management) staying engaged becomes extremely hard, or even impossible. Even the most committed employees just can’t force it out from themselves endlessly without a proper framework and support from the management, even if they wanted to. One interesting fact about engagement at work is, that when asked if people would like to do their best at their work, be successful and make an impact, almost everyone says “yes”. Where does the huge gap from this number to the actual engagement levels come from?
In the next article I will discuss the deeper anatomy of the engagement, what factors impact it most, and what a massive impact the leadership has on it. I will also give a few suggestions on how you can start attacking this challenge, as you most probably have it also in your company on some level, whether you know about it or not.
A couple of interesting resources for more info:
www.gallup.com (various related articles from the last 10 years)
The State of the Global Workplace (219 pages long report): https://www.gallup.com/workplace/238079/state-global-workplace-2017.aspx
The State of the American Workplace (214 pages long report): https://www.gallup.com/workplace/238085/state-american-workplace-report-2017.aspxDeterminants of employee engagement and their impact on employee performance (research report): http://student.bms.lk/GDM/Assignment/MPAssignment/15.pdf Do you know how engaged your employees are? These statistics tell that you probably don’t.
Leadership & Career Articles
- Leadership Lessons – What leaders and managers actually do?
- 10 Top tips for job interviews
- Essential Leadership Skills: Say “No” -even to your boss
- 12 Most important leadership skills
- Essential Leadership Skills: What are good leaders made of?
- Career Management: Questions to ask in a job Interview
- Leadership Lessons: False beliefs and misconceptions about leaders and management careers
- Pursuing a leadership career – why should you lead?
- Essential Leadership Skills: Leading up
- Leadership Lessons: Your identity – you are not your title
- Essential Leadership Skills: How To Lead Remotely
- Essential Leadership Skills: Act Like a Leader
- Essential Leadership Skills: Influence from trust and respect
- Career Management: Choose your position wisely
- Career Management: Choose your company wisely
- Essential Leadership Skills: Decision-making
- Career Management: Career changes to different industries or areas of expertise
- Extreme morning routine for extraordinary results
- How to ask for a raise and negotiate salary – complete guide
- Essential Leadership Skills: Delegating
- Essential Leadership Skills: Employee Engagement
- How to ask for a promotion – complete guide
- Essential Leadership Skills: Crisis Management
- Do you know how amazingly costly it can be to deny a salary raise?
- 13 steps how to get a promotion to your first management position quickly
- 10 reasons why some people get promoted fast and often
- Take ownership of your work – Troubleshooting, Part 2
- Take ownership of your work and start to lead, Part 1
- Keys for building a management career: mentors, coaches and the people around you.